Thats the thing, although they are induvidually horrible and useless at teamwork their choice of ONLY overpowered templates still make them a threat, a threat its hard to deal with since we all play mages.
Like at that idoc the other day, it was easier to pvp against I-C than Nooballiance simply because I-C are less people, easier to read the battles, and they dont have 10 archers 5 necros spamming strangles and mortal strikes. Their 3/5 is imho well deserved.
If it were based on induvidual skill 1 on 1 it would be 1/5, but its not, its the overall factor of the danger level that comes with 15 people attacking you with 15 overpowered templates at once.